RM

Reyes Mezcaleria — Customer Review Insights

821 N Orange Ave, Orlando, FL 32801
Data pulled 2026-05-09
104 customer reviews · 1 location

Reyes Mezcaleria — Orlando, FL

821 N Orange Ave, Orlando, FL 32801 · Downtown North District
Overall Rating
4.43 / 5.00
Across 104 cleaned reviews
5★ Share
77%
80 of 104 reviews
Negative Reviews (1–3★)
13 (12.5%)
vs network avg 12.5%
Last 12 Months Avg
4.43
104 reviews · vs 0.00 prior (0)
Last 3 Months Avg
4.22
32 recent reviews · watch trend

Rating Distribution

How customers rated this location.

Rating by Recency

Average rating across review age buckets — tracks whether quality is steady, improving, or slipping.

Top 3 Improvement Opportunities Negative themes

Top 3 themes from 13 negative reviews (1–3★) and mined snippets from 4★/5★. Each review can map to multiple themes.

Top Improvement Opportunity for Location The fresh-and-recurring problem is the host stand. Every 1★ review from the last week — and several older ones — converges on the same pattern: callers and walk-ins are told one thing then refused at the door, and when customers escalate, the manager either doubles down (Dee W, keuris fernandez) or shuts the dining room down for reasons customers find arbitrary (Jim White, AC closure during dinner service). The improvement bet is a host-and-manager-of-the-day SOP: a single source of truth on table availability, a written script for waitlist conversations, and a manager escalation policy that defaults to "seat the guest, comp the inconvenience" rather than enforcing a closed-room reservation rule against an empty dining floor. Beyond hosting, two secondary fixes would close most of the remaining negatives: (1) an itemized check policy so undisclosed charges like Marggie L's $-per-ice-cube don't surprise upscale guests, and (2) shift-level service tracking so the inconsistency between "impeccable" and "disappeared occasionally" stops showing up in the same week's reviews.

Host stand & manager accountability

Reservation gatekeeping, dismissive front-of-house, and management decisions customers find unprofessional — the dominant pattern in the most recent 1★ reviews
5 reviews mentioning this theme

No professionalism or accountability from management here at all. We called ahead to ask if they had availability and were told yes. We got there maybe 10 minutes later, only to be told it would be a 1-hour wait because they had “a lot of …

Dee W · 1★ · 2 days ago

Used to love coming here, but after the experience we had recently, I honestly don’t plan on coming back. The manager was “lovely” — sarcasm, obviously — and the host wasn’t much better. Just really disappointing overall, especially from a place we actually used to enjoy.

keuris fernandez · 1★ · 2 days ago

Reservation only I was told. Empty seats everywhere. Waste of time but I won’t waste my money on an establishment that think it’s upscale. It’s Mexican food for Pete sakes.

Jay · 1★ · 3 days ago

I went to this restaurant this morning with my friend. When we arrive, we waited for the host to come see us, we waited a whole five minutes for someone to even come talk to us, the restaurant was completely empty. When someone finally came …

Giulia Avila · 1★ · 8 months ago

It's 615 on Sunday and they're closing. Their manager decided to close early because the ac is broken. It's 43 degrees out!

Jim White · 1★ · 3 months ago

Price-to-value perception & surprise charges

Customers expect upscale pricing but feel portions, presentation, or undisclosed line items don't match the bill
5 reviews mentioning this theme

Very expensive. I ordered fish tacos and there were only two tacos, they were awful, they had no presentation and were incredibly expensive. I won't eat there again and I really wouldn't recommend it.

Elvia Andrades · 1★ · 6 months ago

In all honesty this is the worst Mexican restaurant we ever visited. Food was overly price with small portion that can feed little kids and not adult. Shame on this franchise and also menu online is totally different in restaurant. Oyr …

Rishi Bho · 1★ · 6 months ago

Beautiful restaurant, good selection of food and drinks, server was informative & pleasant overall; however, did not inform us of a charge for an ice cube & disappeared occasionally. The lead server understood our concern(s) and corrected …

Marggie L · 4★ · 9 months ago

A little loud for a small crowd. Food is good but quite expensive for this category. Service a little slow not on time

Marco “Revere” G · 4★ · 9 months ago

Some of our dishes were very good. But for the most part, everything was satisfactory. The service was good , not great. Prices were a bit high...but for a city restaurant, I guess this is to be expected. Worth a try.

Dawn Smith · 4★ · 9 months ago

Server attentiveness & service inconsistency

Same restaurant, very different service depending on the shift — disappearing servers, slow timing, or no follow-through
5 reviews mentioning this theme

Server wasn’t as attentive but pretty good. Food was good, margaritas were really good.

Lisa Claiborne · 3★ · a year ago

The food was good but there was a limited selection from the items listed in the menu (including no beef/steak due to changes in the near future to the menu) so the options for protein were pork, chicken or fish. Our server could have done better for sure, I have been there several times with excellent service, not this time.

Yoly Enid · 4★ · a year ago

Beautiful restaurant, good selection of food and drinks, server was informative & pleasant overall; however, did not inform us of a charge for an ice cube & disappeared occasionally. The lead server understood our concern(s) and corrected …

Marggie L · 4★ · 9 months ago

Some of our dishes were very good. But for the most part, everything was satisfactory. The service was good , not great. Prices were a bit high...but for a city restaurant, I guess this is to be expected. Worth a try.

Dawn Smith · 4★ · 9 months ago

A little loud for a small crowd. Food is good but quite expensive for this category. Service a little slow not on time

Marco “Revere” G · 4★ · 9 months ago

Top 3 Strengths What customers love

Themes mentioned across the 5★ reviews. A single review can hit multiple themes.

6
Kevin
3
Chef Wendy
2
Tavey
2
Jenna

Atmosphere & ambiance — "feels like CDMX"

Beautiful interior, intentional decor, and a luxurious-but-relaxed vibe that customers single out as a destination experience
31 mentions (39% of 5★ reviews)

Luxurious Tequila Bar & Restaurant. AMAZING doesn't even begin to describe the food and drinks. If you want a Tequila experience order one of the many flights o the menu. Las Chingonas is a must for you Boss Ladies out there! Look forward to visiting when I travel to Orlando!

Lorena Gomez Ambriz · 5★ · 2 weeks ago

Increible, it felt like a nice restaurant you'd find in cdmx. Loved it. The fact that they had a tamal IN THE LEAF was impressive enough! Pozole was on point. Coming from a mexican though, definitely need more spice. There was no hot sauce …

Courtney Anaya · 5★ · 2 months ago

Reyes Mezcaleria is exactly the kind of spot I look forward to. The décor hits the sweet spot between stylish and relaxed, the bar is stacked with agave gems and tequila‑forward cocktails, and brunch on Sundays is consistently fantastic. …

Trevor Brown · 5★ · 5 months ago

We came here to celebrate a friend’s birthday and had such a good time. The atmosphere is cozy and welcoming, and the decor is beautiful, it really adds to the experience and makes it feel like a special night out. …

Nisha N · 5★ · 7 months ago

Mezcal & tequila program

The agave list — flights, named cocktails ("the Voyage", "Las Chingonas"), and bartender-led pairings — is the strongest competitive moat
14 mentions (18% of 5★ reviews)

This is the standard! Service is A1! The food is amazing. My wife and I got guacamole and queso (best queso I’ve ever had). I also enjoyed a flight called the voyage which set the tone for the rest of the journey. Sure was a great experience! For my entree a to die for lamb birria….. it’s all of that.

Troy Winston · 5★ · 2 weeks ago

Best mezcal list I've seen in a while!

Zak Beard · 5★ · 4 months ago

Luxurious Tequila Bar & Restaurant. AMAZING doesn't even begin to describe the food and drinks. If you want a Tequila experience order one of the many flights o the menu. Las Chingonas is a must for you Boss Ladies out there! Look forward to visiting when I travel to Orlando!

Lorena Gomez Ambriz · 5★ · 2 weeks ago

Great food, great bartenders very attentive, the old fashioned mescal was absolutely amazing 👏. Also had the fish tacos and the ceviche with shrimp and octo add on. Def gotta try that one. Thank for a great time …

Elgin jenkins · 5★ · a month ago

Servers & hospitality (Kevin, Jenna, Gladys, Tavey)

When the floor is staffed well, named servers make the night — and reviewers come back specifically for them
21 mentions (26% of 5★ reviews)

WOW.. i had myself a wonderful brunch with my family hosted by our server Kevin. …

Mikey Conlon · 5★ · 3 months ago

Our server Jenna was lovely! And food is always great!!

Colby Courtois · 5★ · 3 months ago

Gladys, our server, was absolutely lovely and took great care of us. Her suggestions were on point. And she hooked us up with a birthday churro. All together it was an delicious and memorable experience. Chips and salsa and the

Jesse · 5★ · a month ago

Thiago and Jeremy were fenomenal! So attentive and funny! place and decoration are great ! Lots of details Food is delicious! The elote, enchiladas e guacamole were fantastic! I just wish …

Tchello_Thor · 5★ · 4 months ago